This guide helps you navigate the process of choosing a homeschool curriculum. It covers essential questions to ask, teaching methods, popular curriculum options, and budgeting tips.
Most homeschool families report completing core academic subjects in 3-4 hours per day for elementary students, compared to the 6-7 hours typical of traditional schools, due to the one-on-one instruction and absence of classroom management overhead (NHERI, 2024).
Before you buy anything: Know your starting point
Before you start shopping for a homeschool curriculum, take time to figure out what you really need. Spend about thirty minutes on these questions:
-
Why are you homeschooling? If you pulled your child out because school was too slow, look for a curriculum that allows them to speed up. If it’s for religious reasons, you might need faith-based materials. If flexibility is key, choose portable resources that don’t tie you to a strict schedule.
-
What does your child need? Focus on what they actually require right now. If they struggle with reading, they need phonics. If math makes them anxious, find a gentle approach. If they can’t sit still, look for hands-on options. Address real issues, not just ideals.
-
What do you need as the teacher? This is often overlooked. Do you want detailed scripts, or do you prefer flexibility? How much time do you have for planning? Be honest about your style. What works for your friend may not work for you.
Understanding teaching methods
Every curriculum has its own approach to learning. Knowing these can help you find what fits your family best:
-
Traditional/Textbook: Structured lessons and workbooks. Great for families who want a familiar school setup but can feel dull for creative kids.
-
Classical: Focuses on grammar, logic, and rhetoric. Heavy on Latin and memorization. It creates strong readers and writers but needs a lot of parent involvement.
-
Charlotte Mason: Uses living books and nature study. It’s a gentle way to encourage learning but needs parents to curate materials.
-
Montessori: Child-led learning with hands-on materials. Works for self-motivated kids but requires some investment.
-
Unschooling: Learning based on interests without a set curriculum. It fosters independence but demands a lot of parental engagement.
Remember, most programs mix methods. Don't limit yourself because of labels.
Complete curriculum packages: The major players
All-in-one curriculum packages can simplify your choices. Here’s a look at popular options:
-
Sonlight: Focuses on literature and integrates Christian values. It's great for families who love reading together. Costs around $1,000-1,500 per grade level.
-
Abeka: Offers structured Christian curriculum with daily lesson plans. It's rigorous, with packages ranging from $500-900 per grade.
-
The Good and the Beautiful: Blends Charlotte Mason and Christian values at lower prices ($200-400). The materials are beautiful, but some say history can be sanitized.
-
Time4Learning: A digital, self-paced program that’s great for independent learners. Costs about $25-30/month. It may feel a bit impersonal.
-
BookShark: A secular alternative to Sonlight, with a similar approach and prices ($800-1,200).
-
Oak Meadow: Focuses on creativity and holistic development, with costs from $400-700.
Subject-by-subject: Building your own package
Many families prefer to pick curriculums for each subject instead of going for a full package. It allows for more customization:
-
Math: Can be tricky. Saxon Math offers rigorous, incremental learning. Singapore Math builds strong problem-solving skills but needs a parent comfortable with its methods. Math-U-See uses manipulatives, while Teaching Textbooks offers a fully independent, computer-based approach.
-
Language Arts: Includes reading, writing, spelling, and grammar. All About Reading is great for struggling readers, and Logic of English covers phonics and handwriting. IEW teaches writing through structure.
-
Science: Options vary from textbooks to hands-on experiments. Apologia is Christian-based and thorough, while Real Science 4 Kids stays neutral. BFSU is inquiry-based and popular among Charlotte Mason fans.
-
History: Worldview shows up here a lot. Story of the World offers a neutral history cycle, while Sonlight integrates literature. For secular families, Build Your Library is a great option.
Budget tiers: What can you actually expect to spend?
How much you spend on curriculum can vary. According to HSLDA, families spend:
-
Free to $200/year: This is doable. Khan Academy and Ambleside Online offer free resources. Your library can cover literature. Just know you’ll need to curate materials yourself.
-
$200-600/year: There are solid options here. The Good and the Beautiful fits in this range. Teaching Textbooks math costs $55-75 per level.
-
$600-1,200/year: This is the comfortable middle where most families land after their first year.
-
$1,200-2,000+/year: This covers premium packages like Sonlight or memberships like Classical Conversations.
Check if your Education Savings Account (ESA) funds cover specific curricula, as rules can vary by state.
When curriculum isn't working
Switching curriculum happens—and it’s okay. Here are signs it might be time to change:
- Everyone dreads the subject.
- Tears or tantrums are common.
- You’re spending too much time making it work.
- Your child isn’t progressing.
But sometimes it's best to stick it out:
- If it’s just a tough season.
- You’re only a few weeks in.
- The struggle is with the subject, not the program.
If you’ve given it a real try (six to eight weeks), and it’s still not working, it’s fine to change. What you’ve spent matters less than your child’s learning time. Many publishers have good resale value.
The bottom line
Choosing a homeschool curriculum can feel overwhelming, but don’t worry. Research shows homeschooled students often do better academically. The key isn’t finding the perfect program—it’s about engaged teaching from a caring parent. So, pick something that fits your budget and teaching style. Try it out and adjust as needed. Remember, what works for others might not work for you—and that’s perfectly fine. The goal is to find materials that make teaching effective and keep your kids engaged.
Ready to simplify your homeschool?
BetterSchool can help you track compliance, manage records, and plan your curriculum—all in one place.
